Photo: Reuters/Larry Downing

[by Jim Kunstler]

In Iraq?

Neither Jack Murtha, the congressman who set the cable news networks afire this weekend, or Frank Rich, the lead dog on the New York Times Sunday op-ed page, mentioned the word oil once. I only mention it myself because it would be nice if we could have a coherent public discussion about staying or going in Iraq, and you can't do that without talking about the oil of the Middle East.

But it does illustrate how deep the national denial runs and how foggy the debate gets. Even poor George W. Bush seems to think we're in Iraq in order to turn the people into Jeffersonian democrats, so the only issue for his opponents is whether that is possible or not.

Maybe we ought to ask: what happens to the oil supply of the Crusader West when none of its representatives maintains a garrison in the Middle East? I use the term Crusader not to be cute, but to remind you how Europe and America are viewed by many people of the Middle East. They don't like us. They have a longstanding beef with us. Some of them would like to punish us.

America is leading the current crusade because we are the society most desperately addicted to oil, and the Middle East is where two-thirds of the world's remaining oil lies. The one thing that we apparently cannot bring ourselves to talk about is our addiction itself. The commuters whizzing around the edge cities and metroplexes of this land probably got a big charge out of Congressman Murtha's anti-war blast taking over drive-time radio on Friday. I wonder if they thought about how it might affect their commuting.

This whole spectacle -- both the inept war itself and our debate about it here at home -- is particularly shameful for the official opposition, my party, the Democrats, because we could be talking about the so-called elephant-in-the-room, namely how we live in America and the tragic choices we've made, and the things we might do to change that -- but the party leadership is too brain-dead or craven to do that. As long as we don't, we're going to be wrassling a tarbaby in the Middle East.

Unless an anti-war opposition has a plan to withdraw from the project of suburban sprawl, we're going to have to keep soldiers in Iraq, if not in the cities, then out in desert bases guarding the oil works and keeping planes ready to fly in case some al-Zarqawi-type maniac mounts a coup in Saudi Arabia. It would certainly be legitimate for the Democratic party to oppose the idea that we can continue to be crippled by car-dependency, or that we ought to keep subsidizing that way of life -- which Vice-president Cheney called "non-negotiable." We'd better negotiate that or somebody else is going to negotiate it for us, and that is exactly what they are doing with IED's in Iraq and elsewhere.

But without that part of the argument, the debate in congress and on the airwaves is just stupid, because we've left ourselves no real choice.

21 November 05

James Kunstler is the sharpshooting author of The Geography of Nowhere, Home From Nowhere and the recently released novel, The Long Emergency, as well as the only guy in a bowtie Morphizm doesn't want to crush into a bloodied pulp. His doomsday predictions can be had for free at his blog, Clusterfuck Nation, as well as here. Which makes him cool.

GET MORE MORPHIZM

Way of the Samourai
Although he revered American film noir, Jean-Pierre Melville's French take on the brutish narrative helped shaped Hong Kong action cinema: MORE

Dead Eye Genealogy
Rumor has it that Abraham Lincoln was the first photographic president. The cult of the face began here, in these Illinois barebones: MORE

LOAD/STREAM
SLEATER-KINNEY
WATCH:
"Jumpers"
LISTEN:
"Jumpers"
From: The Woods
See Also:
One Beat

THE MARS VOLTA
From: Scab Dates
LISTEN:
"And Ghosted Pouts (Live)"
WMA REAL
LISTEN:
"Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt (Live)"
WMA REAL

KINKSI:
LISTEN:
"Wives of Artie Shaw"
WATCH: QT
LISTEN:
"Hiding Drugs in the Temples Part. 2"
From: Alpine Static

THE CONSTANTINES
LISTEN:
"Love in Fear"
From: Tournament of Hearts

FRUIT BATS
LISTEN:
"Silent Life"
LISTEN:
"Lives of Crime"
WATCH: QT
From: Spelled in Bones

DEATH CAB FOR CUTIE:
"Soul Meets Body"
From: Plans
AUDIO: WMA REAL
See Also: Transatlanticism