 Photo: AP/J. Scott Applewhite
|
Victory?
[by Jim Kunstler]
What on earth does George W. Bush mean by victory? To remake Iraq in the image of Indiana?
I suppose I am the 1,289,654th observer to note that the president does a poor job of articulating the goal of our military venture over there -- which is to defend our access to the oil of the Middle East.
Incessantly flogging the word freedom the past three years was probably his biggest mistake. It would have been more precise, modest, and useful to say that we were supporting elections under a new constitution (written with our assistance) because the alternative would be to just appoint a bunch of guys we liked to be a government -- and that government would have had no legitimacy among the Iraqi people, not to mention the bawling of world opinion against it (and us). So, of course, elections were a necessity, and the policing required to make that happen has been an ugly struggle.
Otherwise, the most conspicuous freedom in Iraq, for most Iraqis, the past three years has been freedom from reliable electrical service.
But victory ? That's really a howler. Over what? The terrorists, I suppose, if you call the larger enterprise a War on Terror, another unfortunate locution. The fact is that there is a vast popular antipathy against the United States that emanates from west of Gibraltar clear across the eastern hemisphere to the south Pacific. In formal terms, it is an Islamic jihad. Its clear goal is to expel interlopers from Islamic territory. It imposes rather severe penalties on the perceived interlopers, and its tactics are not gentlemanly, especially where civilians are in the way.
Victory against this would seem to imply the extermination of at least tens of millions of Islamic young men, not a realistic goal. We are equally unlikely to charm them into a change of affection by demonstrating the art of elections.
Getting back to the smaller theater of Iraq itself, we see a cast of characters arrayed against our presence: Shiites acting as proxies for neighboring Iran; former Baathists seeking crazily to regain control; Sunnis desperately trying to keep a hand in the oil revenue, since most of the oil lies in either Shiite or Kurdish territory; and of course there is probably a contingent of international jihadistas, young men from all over the Middle East and elsewhere, with no regular work except to harass and exasperate the infidel occupiers. There is certainly an inexhaustible supply of these young men. And an inexhaustible supply of munitions at their disposal. There is no chance whatsoever that we are going to pacify these warriors. They will not rest until we depart their ummah and we are not going to do that until there is no oil left in it.
So, victory in any conventional sense that Americans understand this word is out of the question, and the President's use of it is his biggest blunder since the "mission accomplished" stunt of 2003. The Iraq elections may succeed in establishing a legitimate government -- but then what? Will it govern for a month and a half and fall apart? The eventual likely outcome, as everybody knows, is civil war in Iraq, and perhaps a widening conflict with Iran on one side, Syria on the other side, and Saudi Arabia left to the Jihadistas. Elsewhere in the world, things will continue to blow up.
Meanwhile, back here in This Land is Your Land, the easy motoring utopia will remain non-negotiable and we'll drive Amtrak into bankruptcy.
12 December 05
 James Kunstler is the sharpshooting author of The Geography of Nowhere, Home From Nowhere and the recently released novel, The Long Emergency, as well as the only guy in a bowtie Morphizm doesn't want to crush into a bloodied pulp. His doomsday predictions can be had for free at his blog, Clusterfuck Nation, as well as here. Which makes him cool. | GET MORE MORPHIZM
 Analyzing Crow
Devendra Banhart is the new millennium's childlike folk prophet. And he's not afraid to look war in the eye and wonder why: MORE
 Guilin
"Soon the smell of damp earth that hangs over Guilin like a penumbra will surrender, join the cosmopolis already cropping up along the Li, lighting the nocturnal paths of lovers and laborers alike:" MORE
 No Exit, No Return
Just because Sam Fuller's Street of No Return came out as the '90s broke doesn't mean it lacks punch. Quite the opposite: MORE
 Democracy's Dark Side
California is a place where actors turn virtual wars into real ones. It's also a place where they die failures: MORE
 Twisting Things Up
The Heavenly States prove just because the personal is political doesn't mean it sucks. Our interview explains: MORE
 Hating Suburbia
Don't hate Jim Kunstler just because peak oil has passed. Hate the suburban economy, which is about to run dry: MORE
 LBJ VS. GWB!
Two Texas oil barons, two ten-gallon egos. But who wins the history books? Tom McNichol breaks it down: MORE
 Finding Counterculture
The BRMC's Peter Hayes doesn't care if you call him a fucking beatnik. He'll Howl at you just the same: MORE
 Craft Work
Blackalicious doesn't talk the talk of today's hip-hop herd. but will The Craft get the exposure it deserves? MORE
 Destroy the Status Quo
Mashup is more than simple juxtaposition. It's about the shifting Gears. And Z-Trip is readyfor it to happen: MORE
 Way of the Samourai
Although he revered American film noir, Jean-Pierre Melville's French take on the brutish narrative helped shaped Hong Kong action cinema: MORE
 Dead Eye Genealogy
Rumor has it that Abraham Lincoln was the first photographic president. The cult of the face began here, in these Illinois barebones: MORE
|
DEATH CAB FOR CUTIE:
"Soul Meets Body"
From: Plans
AUDIO: WMA REAL
See Also: Transatlanticism
|
 
 
|
