Web Morphizm
subscribe
Laugh until it hurts. " I don't believe in God and openly ridicule those who do, but if I did, I'd thank Him, Her or It for sending Colbert's 'balls-ilicious' comedy earthward."
(Photo: Comedy Central)
Truthiness and Consequences

[by Scott Thill ]

Certain elements of the crew had decided to pretend that it was not a crash but a crash landing that was seconds away. After all, the difference between the two is only one word. Didn't this suggest that the two forms of flight terminaton were more or less interchangeable? How much could one word matter? An encouraging question under the circumstances, if you didn't think about it too long, and there was no time to think right now. The basic difference between a crash and a crash landing seemed to be that you could sensibly prepare for a crash landing, which is exactly what they were trying to do. The news spread through the plane, the term was repeated in row after row. 'Crash landing, crash landing.' They saw how easy it was, by adding one word, to maintain a grip on the future, to extend it in consciousness if not in actual fact...Suddenly, the engines restarted. Just like that. Power, stability, control. -- Don DeLillo, White Noise

There are times when you have to leap into the clusterfuck, and then there are times when you just have to sit back and enjoy the delicious ironies of life. Which is another way of saying that I wasn't late to the blogger party on Stephen Colbert's in-person smackdown of the president of the most powerful country on Earth (for now, anyway, but probably not for long). Rather, I was soaking up the unrestrained love and the hate, and searching for the type of hyperreal hilarity that once belonged to the finest show on television -- Harvey Birdman, Attorney at Law, if you must know -- but now almost wholly belongs to one of that show's flawless talents and his new show, an equally hyperreal laugher on Comedy Central.

Like his soon-to-be-retired Birdman doppleganger Phil Ken Sebben (Falcon Seven, for the cartoon nerds in the audience), Stephen Colbert's blowhard doppleganger has an unquenchable penchant, like the president he skewered, for ignorance and zealotry in equal measure. And he's decided that the most productive way to transmit that ignorance is through language. Phil Ken Sebben is prone to making ludicrous statements, punctuated by a hearty "Ha Ha!" -- which is then followed by a repeat of said statement's core content. (My favorite? "Dangly parts.")

Meanwhile, Colbert's show self-consciously abuses the limits of language to prove that, in the end, reality can take a backseat to fantasy when the right words are weaponized for action. This practice is most capably illustrated in Colbert's "The Word" segment, where terms and phrases are ripped out of their context, destroyed, refashioned as slogans or propaganda, dissected and ridiculed (by Colbert's own right-screen commentator, yet another metafictional element of his vertiginous show), before being then resituated once again in their reality-based meanings, courtesy of the right-screen textual commentator.

Colbert's linguistic satire, of course, reached its apotheosis at the White House Correspondents Dinner, a back-slapping orgy of consensual hallucination that, to mangle Pink Floyd's hyperpolitical missile "Pigs," is "really a laugh/But [it's] really a cry." For so long, the line between fake news of Colbert and Jon Stewart's invention and the "real" news of CBS, NBC, ABC, CNN, Fox, MSNBC, The New York Times, The Washington Post, The Washington Times, The Weekly Standard, The Drudge Report -- Christ, this fucking list goes on forever! -- has been inverted to the extreme. That is, while the "real" news media have fed the American people a steady diet of bullshit built equally by the Bush administration, think-tanks (always a handy repository for those who lost their virginity in their 20s), and a Republican party bursting at the seam with haters of every stripe, The Daily Show and The Colbert Report -- "That's French, bitch!" -- have been answering the late John Lennon's clarion call, "Gimme Some Truth." Though Lennon died too early to see those very "short-haired, yellow-bellied, son[s] of Tricky Dicky" stick around to goose the same, stupor-stoned populace into unnecessary war and wiretapping, Stewart and Colbert have been searching (and outing) the truth -- the reality beneath the Bush administration's "real" -- with a vengeance.

So just what in Hades did Bush and his sycophants (you know who you are) think was going to happen when Colbert took the podium and wrecked shop -- right in Bush's face, I might add? That he would be cowed, awed, intimidated into cojone-less humor? Didn't they watch Stewart on Crossfire? Don't they remember how he handed Begala and Carlson's asses to them, then got their show canceled as one last kick in the nuts before he was done with them? Does anyone even look at Tucker Carlson now without laughing? One suspects that neocon William Kristol, who helped diagram our war of choice in Iraq, wishes he never said that he deserved thanks for helping Colbert get the gig in the first place.

Those, of course, are all rhetorical questions. The answer is, plainly, yes: The Washington establishment thought they could cow Colbert the way they cowed the rest of the media, government and listless American people, who have given Bush free reign to do just whatever the hell he thinks God is telling him to do. To the Iraqis, to the homosexuals, to the Democrats, to the economy, to the nation, to whoever and whatever. That, suck it up, is reality. That is what happened. To all of us.

And the idea that a man who makes his living -- and will be making a better one, if Bush or Pat Robertson's followers don't kill him first -- trafficking in the machinations and complexities of language wasn't going to do the very same to the very man who has made him a full-fledged phenomenon is as telling as the fact that Bush spent time at the same event talking to a simulation of, what else, himself. But it only took one person to make it stick for Colbert's smackdown, albeit one with dual identities speaking in dual modes (truth and "truthiness," which are not the same as Colbert will tell you himself). Meanwhile, the president literalized his dual identities (fearless leader and fear-mongering liar) by employing an impostor to play one of them, not a bad idea. Except that it was followed by a man so adept at language that he got himself invited to a cushy affair where he could both praise and insult the president without restraint, right to his face. To the shock and awe, pun intended, of the so-called journalists and bloggers (you know who you are too) out there who feel, for some inexplicable reason, that Colbert either stunk up the joint or didn't show Bush the proper respect.

As if the worst employee this country has ever had wasn't doing a fine enough job disrespecting the presidency all by himself.

Indeed, the outcry itself had all the earmarks of metafictional madness. Here are a couple of my favorites. See if you can spot the hypocrisies:

-- "Colbert crossed the line." US News and World Report

-- "How do you criticize the president without disrespecting the presidency? Then there's the human dimension. Here's a comedian dissing a man non-stop in front of the subject's wife." Chicago Tribune's blog, The Swamp

-- "Stephen Bridges played 'George W. Bush' in the same way that Stephen Colbert plays a pompous talk-show host named 'Stephen Colbert' who interviews 'real' people in politics. Bridges was successful, because he brought along a 'real' person ready and willing to take part in the joke." Robert George, Huffington Post

-- "Consensus: Colbert did indeed bomb." David Frum, National Review

-- "Self-mockery can be funny. Mockery that is insulting is not." Some loser from the Washington Post

-- "Insulting the Prophet is one thing, but insulting Stephen Colbert, the patron saint of the piously correct left! That's really blasphemy." Nathan Gardels, Huffington Post

OK, that's enough. Every stomach -- and well-defined sense of irony -- has its limits. To start with the unnamed critic (wimp!) in the U.S. News and World Report, which line Colbert actually crossed is not expressed. Would it be constructing an appearance on false pretenses? Insulting intelligence, not of the national security variety but of the audience? This president has crossed so many lines during his nearly six years in office that it's insulting to make me find all the necessary hyperlinks to illustrate my case.

How about The Swamp's lament for the "human dimension?" Not too convincing, especially when you're talking about a guy who calls butchered civilians "collateral damage," right before he refuses to count them. Or one whose administration terms raining incendiaries from the skies "shock and awe." A guy who flew over Katrina's aftermath, to get a better look at the "real" situation.

Fine then. How about the misguided concretizations of Robert George? Amatuer night. "Stephen Bridges played 'George W. Bush' in the same way that Stephen Colbert plays a pompous talk-show host named 'Stephen Colbert' who interviews 'real' people in politics?" Did he now? Really? Aside from being a nice example of a logical fallacy known as "X is the common thread," George's conflation of Colbert and Bridges misfires because it fails to recognize the obvious, which is that Colbert interviews real politicians, while Bridges' "real" interview was, in fact, a constructed charade. The parallel would have been apt had Bush, for example, decided to conduct the schizo monologue by himself. The fact that he brought a real person (not a "real" person, George, come on!) goes to show that he cannot comprehend the complexities of metafiction, which is exactly what Bush's stunt with Bridges attempted to pull off. Right before it sucked ass.

On to Frum's judgment that "Colbert bombed." Did he indeed? Which country? Last time I checked, the only guy on the stage who had bombed anyone was Bush himself. And he's bombed the shit out of pretty much everyone he can get away with, and wants to bomb more. Frum was using a metaphor, you say? Employing a general colloquialism to manipulate the collective recall of the event? Ah, got it. My point exactly. Language is power. Except when you don't know how it works. Especially against you. Which explains the "Consensus" stab in Frum's banal jab. To quote Inigo Montoya in The Princess Bride: "You keep saying that word. I do not think it means what you think it means."

As for the Washington Post hack's theorizations of the nuances of "mockery," I'm speechless. Unlike Colbert, who more fully understands what the term mockery means than anyone I've watched in recent memory. The fact that he attacks it from both ends (the real and the hyperreal) means that he's got it on lockdown. The Post hack, otherwise known as Richard Cohen, has a little bit of it, as evidenced by the first sentence of his clumsily arranged criticism: "First, let me state my credentials: I am a funny guy." You sure are, dude. I laughed my ass off reading your column, as well as the "fact" that you're so funny is , as you state, "well known in certain circles." Which circles, one asks? Who knows? Maybe they're located somewhere near that line Colbert wasn't supposed to cross.

Then there is Gardels' particularly huffy (no disrepect, Arianna, you're the ma'am!) comeback, which was about as long as a third-grader's book report. (OK, that's not fair to the third-grader.) Adopting religious metaphor when criticizing those who criticize Bush makes about as much sense as calling a free pass for polluters The Clean Skies Act. Remember, Gardels, this is a guy who says God told him to invade Iraq, which so far has led to thousands of inhabited body bags and the loss of billions of dollars. And the best you can do is tar Colbert as a leftist saint? Really? Like I said earlier, amateur hour. Or in the case of Gardels, amateur 127 words.

The truth, or truthiness, is this: Colbert's attack on Bush was the bravest thing any entertainer has accomplished this year. He's fashioned a simulation so startlingly coherent and productive that Republican tools like Kristol, Michael Brown (!), Lou Dobbs and countless more are lining up around the block to appear on his show. Better yet, they think that doing so will give them a sorely needed image makeover. That is, rather than do something real to save their skins, they'd rather subject themselves to the hyperreal ravings of a Bill O'Reilly-like madman. They'd rather sit through someone who lampoons the nation's most grievous ills by pretending to approve of them than actually set about fixing any of them. And that is why they invited Colbert to Washington, and that is why he roasted all of them like the pigs they are.

I don't believe in God and openly ridicule those who do -- man, is it ever fun! -- but if I did, I'd thank Him, Her or It for sending Colbert's "balls-ilicious" comedy earthward. Just in time for Armageddon.

May 4, 2006

Let The Music Play: Join EFF Today
GET MORE MORPHIZM

I Am Not a DJ
Part laptop tourism, part hip-hop purism, Blockhead's Downtown Science needs no Shadow. Our interview explains: MORE

V For Vague
Unlike Alan Moore's canonical comic, the film V For Vendetta is heavy on the popcorn and light on the philosophy: MORE

Batty Dread
The Boston Red Sox's Manny Ramirez may be an overgrown kid, but he still took his team into the history books: MORE

Garrison State
Muslims rioting. Americans killing. Too bad no one's made a film called Why We Fight. Wait, Eugene Jarecki has! MORE

Songs About Fucking
The Motor City's Demolition Doll Rods like it hard and raw. Their rock and roll, that is. And they're putting out nightly: MORE

Sixteen Scandals
From Katrina videotapes to Dubai port deals, the Bush clan can't stop fucking up. Where's Long Duc Dong when you need him? MORE

We're Shocked! Shocked!
The White House just found over 250 pages of emails relating to the Plame case. Someone call Claude Rains: MORE

Toon Town
The cartoons that pissed off Muslim Nation came out months ago. But can't a suffering people call bullshit anyway? MORE

Hyper-Famous Amos
Now that her video set Fade to Red is on the shelves, Tori Amos is looking more and more like a movie star: MORE

The Plame Game
Alberto Gonzales is now withholding Plame emails from the Fitzgerald investigation. Is anyone surprised? MORE

Keeping It Sane
Before he passed, Bill Hicks was committed to speaking truth to insanity. A new DVD shows we need him more than ever: MORE

Something in My Toe
"But one can never be sure about anything. And that is the one thing I've always been sure about:" MORE

Moving Backward
The gaze-hop of Dalek has broken borders. Why the world is still conservative is another story: MORE

1926-2005
The year that was created many casualties. But none as tragic as the underrated blues giant RL Burnside: MORE

Only One
"All of which serves as a humorous reminder of the Order of Things. Some appetites carry a heavy price:" MORE

Democracy's Dark Side
California is a place where actors turn virtual wars into real ones. It's also a place where they die failures: MORE

Twisting Things Up
The Heavenly States have proven that just because the personal is political doesn't mean it sucks. Our interview explains: MORE

Dead Eye Genealogy
Rumor has it that Abraham Lincoln was the first photographic president. The cult of the face began here, in these Illinois barebones: MORE

Guilin
"The smell of damp earth that hangs over Guilin will surrender, and join the cosmopolis cropping up along the Li:" MORE

Hollywood Uncensored
In this age of FCC jihads, it's clear we haven't come a long way baby. Before the Production Code legislated decency into pop culture, these pre-Code standouts reigned supreme: MORE

"The Ship is Sinking"
Fitting that ...and You Will Know Us By the Trail of Dead's rawk evokes the Apocalypse. Because their new album thinks we're going to hell in hurry: MORE

Getting an Edge
Zach Smith's Pinback has released the year's most addictive album. But he still harbors the healthy anger that indie rock credibility erases: MORE

Body and Soul
Long before he was an auteur, Robert Bresson spent a year suffocating beneath Nazi occupation. How he got labeled an optimist is another story: MORE

Not-So-Intelligent Design
Terminology is becoming today's lethal toxin. Privatization has become personalization, polluted air has become a clear sky: MORE

Way of the Samourai
He revered American film noir, but Jean-Pierre Melville's reach extends to Hong Kong action cinema: MORE

Gain and Loss
The post-rock of Continental was already heavily emotional. But when the band lost a close friend, the game changed for good: MORE

LBJ VS. GWB!
Two Texas oil barons, two ten-gallon egos. But who wins the history books? Tom McNichol breaks it down: MORE

Pharisaical Thinking
Who doesn't like the year-end flashback? But you're still going to get one from us, even if 2005 was a year to forget: MORE

The Violent Truth
David Cronenberg spent a career tearing bodies apart and putting them back together. Now History of Violence is doing the same with the mind: MORE

LOAD/STREAM



MELLOWDRONE
LISTEN: "Fashionably Uninvited" MP3
LISTEN: “Oh My” MP3


THE SUGARCUBES
WATCH: "Deus"
REAL WMA QUICK
WATCH: "Motorcrash"
QUICK REAL WMA

THE PRETENDERS
Listening Party
Pirate Radio
REAL WMA QUICK

LISTEN: Sixteen-song sampler from Remain in Light, Fear of Music and more
REAL WMA


DEATH CAB FOR CUTIE
WATCH:
Directions (DVD)
QUICK REAL WMA
"Soul Meets Body"
From: Plans
AUDIO: WMA REAL
See Also:
Ben Gibbard on Politics
Transatlanticism

TORI AMOS
From: Fade to Red The Video Collection

FLAMING LIPS
From: At War With the Mystics
LISTEN:
"The W.A.N.D."
QT WMA

THE MARS VOLTA
From: Scab Dates
STREAM THE ENTIRE ALBUM HERE:
REAL WMA


SLEATER-KINNEY
WATCH:
"Jumpers"
LISTEN:
"Jumpers"
From: The Woods
See Also:
One Beat

KINKSI:
LISTEN:
"Wives of Artie Shaw"
WATCH: QT
LISTEN:
"Hiding Drugs in the Temples Part. 2"
From: Alpine Static

THE ELECTED
From: Sun Sun Sun
LISTEN:
Not Going Home

THE MARS VOLTA
From: Scab Dates
STREAM THE ENTIRE ALBUM HERE:
REAL WMA
LISTEN:
"And Ghosted Pouts (Live)"
WMA REAL
LISTEN:
"Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt (Live)"
WMA REAL

SLEATER-KINNEY
WATCH:
"Jumpers"
LISTEN:
"Jumpers"
From: The Woods
See Also:
One Beat

NIRVANA
From: Sliver
LISTEN:
"Blandest (Demo)"
WMA REAL
LISTEN:
Sappy
WMA REAL
LISTEN:
"Do Re Mi (Solo Acoustic)"
WMA REAL

KINKSI:
LISTEN:
"Wives of Artie Shaw"
WATCH: QT
LISTEN:
"Hiding Drugs in the Temples Part. 2"
From: Alpine Static

THE CONSTANTINES
LISTEN:
"Love in Fear"
"Soon Enough"
From: Tournament of Hearts

FRUIT BATS
LISTEN:
"Silent Life"
LISTEN:
"Lives of Crime"
WATCH: QT
From: Spelled in Bones

Save the Internet: Click hereSupport Bloggers' Rights!
Sony BMG Rootkit Settlement