"What Hasn't Been Sanitized and Homogenized?": An Interview with John Sayles and Maggie Renzi, Sunshine State (con.)

Cynthia Fuchs

Southern comfort. "Her Southern-ness is based on Tennessee Williams and theatricality. But at the same time, she's working with disadvantaged and troubled children."

CF: Jane Alexander's Delia, at the end, works that system better than the corporate flunky, when she comes up with the escalation clause.
Maggie Renzi: But she also never liked that motel, so she's glad to be rid of it and be well paid for it. As far as she's concerned, the area is already ruined; the birds aren't living there anymore.
JS: And the surprise with that character is that at first she seems like a flake. Her Southern-ness is based on Tennessee Williams and theatricality. But at the same time, she's working with disadvantaged and troubled children and she's running a nonprofit theater, has to know how to handle a business and donors, and she's an ecologist. So she's one of the few people in the town who does have a larger view, and she's saying here, "You people are going to win, but you're going to pay what you should pay." Everybody else is selling short.
MR: And she'll write a big check to the Nature Conservancy.
JS: And when her husband, Ralph Waite's character says they'll "turn that beach into a damn strip mall," she says, "It's not exactly in pristine condition now, is it?" She sees what's happened already.

CF: And Marly's face is so telling at that moment.
JS: Right, because she's dismissed and been embarrassed by her mother for so many years. One of the things that I loved about what the actresses did was, I wrote the characters' dialogue with very different rhythms, and they captured that. So Delia's way is to guild everything in these long Southern Gothic sentences, and Marly is very blunt, her humor is self-deprecatory. They're both Southerners, but they've taken this different tack with it.

CF: It seems that many themes in your films emerge from a sense of place.
JS: Yes. As I do these contemporary movies, as opposed to period movies, one great question is: will there be any place left? The beginning of Limbo has that line one guy says, "Think about Alaska as one big theme park." That's just the beginning of it. This, in Sunshine State, is the fruition of it, where they've been destroying the place for 120 years. When we were thinking about the music for this film, we could think of Lynyrd Skynyrd and Ray Charles, but when you go to Jacksonville, there's reggae bands, Celtic bands, ska bands. It's very eclectic. Everything is so accessible now, everyone listens to everything. The days when you could listen to Sonny Boy Williamson or Hank Williams, and then when it turned into rock n roll -- all that's gone. It's rare to find a sound that's unique to a place anymore. That's an issue I'm dealing with here: what is going to happen when this next generation of kids? What is their culture but media culture? What hasn't been sanitized and homogenized into something like Old Buccaneer Days? I think Americans have a love-hate relationship with the idea of roots in small towns, and certainly that's where Desirée and Marly are focused, though they're going in different directions -- Angela back home, with a hunger for family, and Edie moving away, and realizing, "I Have to stop living my father's dream, and I have to disappoint him, or I'm going to drown."

CF: And she starts to imagine a way out that does not involve a boyfriend or husband.
JS: Marly is a woman who's never had her own thing -- her mother has her theater, her brothers were the basketball players. She had this vague idea about being an oceanographer, but she didn't chase it. She wants a dream. She was with the rock n roll guy when he was rock n roll, and then when he didn't do that anymore, she dumped him. She starts getting interested in Tim Hutton's character when she hears him talk so lovingly about this landscape architect. She's interested in Scotty because he has this dream. So I put her in the water at the end of the movie, and you hope that this time she's going to go after something that is about her instead of whatever guy she's with, or her family, or whatever outside force. And that's a long arc for a lot of people.

From The Sopranos to the dumps. "Marly is a woman who's never had her own thing. She had this vague idea about being an oceanographer, but she didn't chase it. She wants a dream."

CF: And the film does look especially at that connection and break and connection "arc" between generations.
JS: For me, social history and personal history are so closely tied. Nobody starts from scratch: everyone has baggage. And the process of growing up is all about that connection and break. You can't live your parents' dreams. It's interesting that, among the things that separate people -- not just race, not just class -- but also generations. And that's about change. Ralph Waite's character could have done the Lester Maddox thing; he could have stood in front of his restaurant with an axe handle, fighting for segregation and been a hero to the old boys he had lunch with every day. And he didn't do it, though he probably had mixed feelings about not doing it. And now he says, integration came and it wasn't that big a deal, 30 years later. For Marly, black people come in and out all the time and it doesn't mean anything to her -- that's a generational thing.
MR: I was thinking about your questions, that it says a lot about the other movies that we see that place doesn't matter. You can shoot in Toronto, because nobody will know the difference. Generations are not represented. You don't see people with children or parents, unless it's about their children dying or being kidnapped.
JS: They're props.
MR: Yes. When I think about what makes our movies work and be authentic, it's that in the other movies, they're always about two people who each have one friend, no relatives, no obligations. They don't really have jobs and they're not really from anywhere. I put all those things in a list and I think, "No wonder I don't really like to go to the movies."
JS: But I don't think that's a modern phenomenon. In the Golden Age of Hollywood, there was a created America, and it was Warner Bros.' "urban America" or "Andy Hardy." Then it became John Hughes' Middle America, which kind of also a dream world. And every once in a while there was something out of Hollywood that was a little more specific, but that would upset people, and the last thing the studios wanted to do was upset people.

CF: At the same time, while young consumers process information so quickly and at such a huge rate, it remains a sheltered global product, in a way. So much exposure and so little context.
MR: It's shallow.
JS: That's not new either. When Roots aired, the network heard from people who were upset because they never knew about slavery. Or, our friend John Cusack was in Fat Man and Little Boy, about making the atom bomb. And we saw it and he asked what we thought, and I said I didn't love the movie. And he said, yeah, some things work and some things don't. And I said, "There's this one scene with Paul Newman and all these guys: what was that about?" And John said, "They had this test screening and 20 percent of the audience didn't know that because we were talking about the atom bomb, that we were also talking about WWII. So they had to put in a scene where these guys come into Newman's office and say 'Nazis' four times." And it's a five minute scene! My feeling is, forget that 20 percent. They're going to like or not like the movie for other reasons than whether it explains their history for them. That was ten years ago. I bet it's 40 percent now!

More Film Reviews

"I think that there's been a lot of difficulty in defining what is American, what is considered American. There's a lot of difficulty with acceptance within our community of foreignness at this time."

"Dogtown is basically West L.A., where all of L.A. points at the beach. Like we say in the film, the end of Route 66."

"OK, it's a Tom Cruise movie. But try to forget all that machinery, and you may notice how Minority Report astutely links such oppression and exploitation with technologies of seeing."

"Though it might be argued that Nicholas Cage roaring and contorting in slow motion makes for good action cinema, it's hardly the basis for a thoughtful interrogation of how war reinforces systemic racism."

"None of what's wrong will matter for Star Wars fans, because the information will keep folks buzzing for years."

"I think The Last Picture Show would have been an art picture today. It sort of was then. But all films were released slowly in those days; that didn't change until The Godfather and Jaws."

"As much as people still decry Lynch's extensive use of what have come to be known as Lynchian archetypes, they are just colors on the palette that his self-styled film paintings require to run their non-linear -- unless you consider the infinity symbol linear, that is -- course to doom, alienation and deferral."

CF: In this context of history and lack of it, what is your sense of these designed communities, the developers' vision?
JS: I think it has to do with that love-hate relationship with small town America, that desire to be able to go out and do whatever we want and not have any roots. The developed community -- including invented traditions, like Buccaneer Days -- is the result of that kind of schizophrenia. It has some of the hallmarks of a small town, in that you can pretend that, back in that small town ideal America, races weren't fighting with each other. But because it's controlled -- and Walt Disney was one of the first guys to think about it, that's what he was doing next, after the theme parks -- you don't have to do all that work. It's run by a corporation. There seems to be this feeling like, "I just can't think about it anymore! I want to live in a place where life is peaceful and managed, and there won't be any surprises." Like the old Holiday Inn thing. To me, there's something basically classist and racist about it. That probably isn't the first thing that the people who purchase it think about. They think they're looking for security and comfort. And historically, where we were shooting on Amelia Island -- a third of that island is a gated community -- that was started by the guy who started the whole concept of those islands, on Hilton Head. And if you go back further in history, those islands were plantation islands, but with almost no white people living on them. And some of them were actually free black islands. And after the Civil War, they had this idea to ship all the black people to those islands, so they wouldn't have to worry about them. Then in the late '40s and early '50s, people started saying, "Oh we have to put resorts on those islands and turn profits." And there was this island by island thing, where they came, and bought them out for chump change generally, or they just took the deeds, saying, "I don't care if you've been here for eight generations: you were slaves. Now we have the deeds, beat it." Now, almost none of those islands maintains the old Gullah culture.
MR: And American Beach is really an incredible story.

CF: Yes, I've read the Russ Rymer book [American Beach: A Saga of Race, Wealth, and Memory, 1998, about Amelia Island's history as the first black resort].
MR: So who knows what's going to happen to that place now. MaVynee Betsch, who's the last activist keeping the history and memories together, has been ill for so long. There's no community left anymore -- whether it goes to the white or black developers remains to be seen, but it's another piece of Florida that's up for grabs.

CF: It's so frustrating because there's a pervasive feeling of hopelessness -- there's no stopping this encroachment -- and you need to make enough money to survive the week.
JS: One of the things I'd like people to think about is that, yes, there are things that are out of our control, but there's also the possibility of resistance and a responsibility, even just to ask the questions. What's going around you? Read the materials that are available to you.
MR: We live in rural New York State, and they sent around a questionnaire recently, "Do we want a heliport?"
JS: And how many people are going to benefit from that? I think we have been conditioned to accept without complaint that this kind of thing just happens. Certainly, the version of free market capitalism that has been bandied about, starting sometime around Nixon and going through Clinton and Bush, is that this absolute free market is necessary. I mean, what's the NAFTA treaty? It asserts, "We have your best interests in mind. And you don't get to vote on it, as a matter of fact, and neither does your representative." We know a lot of young people who go to the World Trade Organization protests, and these people are our main hope.
MR: If the Dr. Lloyds can live long enough, and that's a real question, that younger generation will need us. We definitely know how to turn up, but we are no longer the center of energy. So much of Sunshine State is about how people get busy with their lives, little things that occupy them: a gambling problem, or the tourist board, or the problems you're having with your kids. And stuff slips by you, and decisions are being made all the time. And you wake up one day and think, "There didn't used to be a gas station there. How did that happen?"